Round 8 – Gold Coast Suns v Melbourne

Liam Chambers

Two games from seven. The worst percentage in the competition. A laundry list of pre season surgeries. An injury depleted back line. No wonder Melbourne is struggling to convince the world of AFL that they have a chance.

However, their performances in the last two games has given the Dees a glimmer of hope that they may still be in contention come September.

Though the Suns had won more games and were above the Demons on the ladder, Melbourne were still somehow favourites to take the honours in Round 8.

It was a tight game which Melbourne dominated; they led the Suns for most of the match but were unable to stretch their lead by further than a couple of goals.

Melbourne threw body and soul at Gold Coast but their skills set let them down at crucial moments. They kicked thirteen minor scores to their six goals. The good news is Tom McDonald kicked half of those goals. That will give his confidence a boost. The fact that he almost kicked a fourth in the last second didn’t matter as hitting the upright meant Melbourne won by a single point.

The bad news is the injury to Michael Hibberd. He has been involved in some goal saving plays in the last few games and those skills will be sorely missed. Jordan Lewis and Jake Melksham were also injured but may yet play in Perth.

I believe the wins in Rounds 7 & 8 will have been an enormous confidence boost for Melbourne after losing five of their first six matches. The fact that they hung in and kept battling to the last second, literally, showed a vital determination to win. The young Marty Hore was an inspiration, scoring a crucial goal when all seemed lost.

Of course next week will be the ultimate test of the Demons’ character. Their Round 9 opponents are the reigning champions and their home ground in Perth is the most inhospitable venue any visiting team could imagine.

Whether the ghosts of last year’s preliminary final defeat can be laid to rest remains to be seen. Melbourne will be the supreme underdogs. The crowd will bay for their blood, like the spectators in the Colosseums of ancient Rome. We will either be fed to the lions or we will be miraculously victorious. Go the Dees!

GOLD COAST     2.1     3.3     5.6     9.6 (60)
MELBOURNE     3.2     3.5     5.9     8.13 (61)

GOALS
Gold Coast: Ainsworth 2, Holman 2, Wright, Lemmens, MacPherson, Powell, Corbett
Melbourne: T.McDonald 3, Melksham, Harmes, Hunt, Petracca, Hore

BEST
Gold Coast: Swallow, Macpherson, Holman, Ainsworth, Hanley, Witts
Melbourne: Oliver, Jones, Melksham, Harmes, Salem, McDonald

Round 7 – Melbourne Vs Hawthorn – Demons Battle Hawks To The Siren

Liam Chambers

Melbourne desperately needed a win to have any chance of playing finals this year. As in previous weeks, they burst out of the blocks in the first quarter, Angus Brayshaw scoring the opener for the Dees. The sides looked evenly matched with Luke Breust scoring the Hawks’ first midway through the opening term. Jayden Hunt restored Melbourne’s advantage but three unanswered goals from Gunston, Breust and O’Meara put Hawthorn in the driver’s seat at the end of the term.

Billy Stretch got one back for the Demons at the start of the second quarter. Melbourne played with greater confidence taking more contested possessions but unfortunately turned the ball over too often for comfort. The positive signs continued though with James Harmes playing a pivotal role in keeping the Dees in the game. A late goal from Bayley Fritsch narrowed the margin to 9 points at the end of the half.

Whatever Simon Goodwin said at half time certainly did the trick. After a shaky start, back to back goals from Nathan Jones and Jeff Garlett gave Melbourne the lead for the first time since the middle of the first quarter. Then Luke Breust restored the Hawks’ lead with his third goal of the afternoon. However Tom McDonald and Jayden Hunt responded quickly to ensure the momentum remained with the Dees. With Alex Neal-Bullen scoring Melbourne’s fifth for the term, the signs for a Dees’ win were brightening, despite a late Gunston goal.

The final quarter is the one where Melbourne has traditionally struggled in tight games. With a fourteen point margin, they needed to be at their most aggressive to ensure a victory didn’t slip from their grasp. Two early goals from Hawthorn gave Demon fans the jitters and there were a few nail biting moments, especially when Hawks’ legend Jarrod Roughead put his team in front at the midway point.

The Dees steadied though and two quick goals from Jay Lockhart (a star of the future) and man of the match James Harmes gave hope that we could claim line honours. Harmes had done a amazing job of keeping O’Meara out of the match thus weakening Hawthorn’s game. A goal from Luke Breust with less than ten minutes remaining meant the play went down to the wire. With Melbourne only managing to put one more point on the scoreboard, the pressure from Hawthorn became increasingly desperate.

Demon fans across the country and overseas were willing the clock to move faster as the remaining seconds ticked away. When the final siren sounded, the relief from players, fans and coaches was immense. Goodwin was hugging anyone and everyone as his side finally began to look like the team that made the semi finals last season.

Now focus turns to the Suns next weekend when Melbourne visits the Gold Coast. It’s a must win game, not least because the following four rounds are all against potential Grand Final teams. For the moment though let’s savour a well earned victory.

MELBOURNE 2.3 4.5 9.10 11.13 (79)
HAWTHORN 4.5 5.8 7.8 11.8 (74)

GOALS
Melbourne: Hunt 2, Brayshaw, Stretch, Fritsch, Jones, Garlett, McDonald, Neal-Bullen, Lockhart, Harmes
Hawthorn: Breust 4, Gunston 3, O’Meara, Lewis, Shiels, Roughead

BEST
Melbourne: Harmes, Gawn, Hibberd, Salem, Oliver
Hawthorn: Gunston, Shiels, O’Meara, Hardwick, Worpel

May our current heirs to the spirit of Tommy Wills in the red and blue ‘find something’ to rally, gain momentum and show pride in the colours

Nigel Dawe

Well if you’re anything like me, in the space of a month and a half you’ve probably gone from gleefully scheming a week or two off at the end of September so as to see that elusive premiership number 13, to wondering what the hell has gone wrong?

Have we simply dropped our zen-inspired Roosy built bundle, did the rest of the competition work us out and just matter-of-factly make amends over the summer, was Jesse Hogan the ‘missing link’ to potency up forward after all, or did the Prelim debacle in Perth so utterly erode our team’s belief in achieving the unbelievable? If any of us could answer this Alice-like rabbit hole cluster of questions, then I guess Simon Goodwin would soon be out of a job.

The great battle-forged Winston Churchill once sneeringly roared: “Success is the ability to go from one failure to another with no loss of enthusiasm.” And sadly, I can more than relate to this adage as a long loyal Melbourne fan (I was going to say ‘suffering’, but there have been many moments of joy over the years, however in times like these they’re easy to lose sight of if you let the down-turns determine your emotions).

I’ve more than once remarked to mates, that even if I played one solitary game for the Dees and I got absolutely pole-axed before I got a single touch and spent the next 6 months in a coma, I could say for the rest of my life, when I came to, that I played for the Melbourne Demons and it was the highlight of my life!

One of my favourite photos of the last 10 years (well there’s two actually) one is of the Jet & the second is of Big Maxy, both are sitting quietly in the rooms before a game looking immerse-fully at their guernseys – about to put them on ‘for real’, an honour your one-eyed fan could only imagine.

And it is that ‘magic’ of playing the game like men but enjoying it like little boys, that I hope each week’s first 18 might draw upon, rekindle and conjure within themselves for the sake of the entire team and the oldest footy club in the world.

As such, may our current heirs to the spirit of Tommy Wills in the red and blue ‘find something’ to rally, gain momentum and show pride in the colours as we head deeper into the business end of the season, because all is not lost, not by any remote stretch of the imagination.

Round 6 – Richmond Vs Melbourne – Tigers Sink Their Teeth Into Demons’ Defence

Liam Chambers

To borrow an old football adage, it was a game of two halves. Melbourne were dominant in the first quarter again and remained competitive up until midway through the third. Then Richmond showed why they are so difficult to beat. No matter how hard the Dees ran and tackled, they couldn’t get through the Tigers’ back line to put enough points on the scoreboard. Although they looked much improved from the side that succumbed to St Kilda in Round 5, Melbourne was unable to maintain the momentum.

Though the first goal went to Tom Lynch (definitely contender for the Coleman Medal), the Dees were winning more contested possessions. Tim Smith scored first for Melbourne before Jay Lockhart doubled their advantage. Max Gawn added another six points before Castagna got one back for Richmond. Then a Jayden Hunt goal was quickly countered by the Tiger’s Brandon Ellis. Melbourne led by six points at the end of the quarter mainly due to their superior tally of contested possessions.

In the second quarter, a goal from Richmond’s Liam Baker levelled the scores. Though Melbourne were defending well they were let down by their kicking efficiency. The Tigers were finding their way to the Dees inside 50 with increasing ease but not converting their advantage. Finally Dustin Martin got Richmond’s second goal of the quarter while being on the receiving end of an accurate Jack Riewoldt kick. The half ended with Melbourne trailing 34-26.

Into the second half and Alex Neal-Bullen scored the Dees’ first goal since Q1 to reduce the margin to four points. Melbourne were still struggling to regain the lead though. Then back to back goals from Riewoldt saw the Tigers in the ascendancy. The momentum was definitely with Richmond at the end of the quarter but the game was still very much within Melbourne’s reach.

The Tigers stepped up the pressure in the fourth quarter and kicked five goals to the Dees’ solitary effort from Bayley Fritsch. Richmond seem to be able to maintain a level of intensity that few teams can match. It’s often been said that they thrive on chaos. At times in the last quarter, there seemed to be three Tigers on the field for every Demon.

There was much to like about Melbourne in Round 6. Angus Brayshaw and Clayton Oliver again starred in midfield with 29 disposals apiece. Max Gawn dominated with 48 hitouts. Christian Salem was calm and collected while diffusing attacks and clearing the ball. The team spirit is there but for some reason the players don’t seem to be gelling the way they did at the end of last season.

The Soothsayers all predicted a top four spot for the Dees in 2019 and fans expectations were sky high. At 5 losses to 1 win for the season so far, our prospects for a finals berth are starting to diminish. To have any realistic chance of making the top eight, we need to win a minimum of twelve games. With sixteen matches left, we need at least eleven to go our way. Even then percentage is hugely important.

The precedent for optimism would be the Swans in 2017 who finished sixth after losing their first six games. There’s no reason Melbourne can’t replicate that result but we face some tough sides in the next four games. Then there’s the Pies, Freo and the Lions. Still, that’s what being a footy fan is all about and there’s still a chance. 47,147 members can’t be wrong!

RICHMOND 3.1 5.4 7.9 12.13 (85)
MELBOURNE 4.1 4.2 5.5 6.6 (42)
GOALS
Richmond: Riewoldt 2, Ellis 2, Castagna 2, Baker 2, Lynch, Ellis, Martin, McIntosh
Melbourne: Smith, Lockhart, Gawn, Hunt, Neal-Bullen, Fritsch
BEST
Richmond: Vlastuin, Houli, Prestia, Lambert, Baker, Riewoldt
Melbourne: Gawn, Melksham, Hibberd, T.McDonald, Brayshaw, Viney

Round 5 – Melbourne Vs St Kilda – Saints Cast Demons Aside (Not a Good Friday)

Liam Chambers

After last week’s triumph over the Swans, it seemed like Melbourne had finally got their season belatedly on track. Though not perfect, there was much in that game to inspire Dees’ fans.

So what went wrong in Round 5? There has been speculation of tension between some coaching staff and some players. If correct, this obviously doesn’t help anyone in the team and adds to the overall stress levels within the club.

Simon Goodwin has helped Melbourne achieve a lot over the last couple of years, slowly building up the strength and confidence after so many years struggling to be competitive. As Max Gawn pointed out in his Bluey Medal speech last year, the support and co-operation of all the staff had been pivotal to how much was achieved in 2018.

There may need to be a bit of re-jiggling and reshaping if the Dees are to recapture that level of performance. Other teams have been through times where the practical outcomes don’t match the intentions. We need to get through this spell of bad results.

We can still make finals and that should be our only focus when the Dees run onto the ground. No one is unbeatable and we can beat anyone.

There were times when the lads played well but we were behind St Kilda at the end of every quarter. I wrote after Round 3 that we often under estimate our opponents in games we should win.

The Saints have improved with every match they’ve played. They only lost by 5 points to Fremantle at home in Round 3 and last week’s effort against Hawthorn was impressive. I really believe we didn’t give them enough respect and we paid the price.

At the start of the first quarter when Preuss opened the scoring with his first touch, it looked like the Dees meant business. However, within minutes we were being out marked and struggling in defence. Preuss again book ended the first quarter with another great goal to raise the fans spirits.

Preuss’ goal may have proved inspirational as we dominated play for most of the second quarter. The midfield played well again, assisted by Gawn’s accuracy in the ruck. Unfortunately we couldn’t find a way through the Saints back line.

Then St Kilda returned serve, dominating contested possession and kicking three goals to be 15 points ahead at half time. Unfortunately the worst was yet to come with St Kilda kicking five unanswered goals in the third quarter.

Melbourne rallied in the fourth to reduce the margin to 28 points but never looked like reigning in the Saints, who iced the cake with two goals in the last minute of play.

We face Richmond in Round 6. The Tigers have had their own set backs this year but are now looking formidable and will be very hard to beat. It will be interesting to see how we react after all the slings and arrows from the media and commentators in general.

If Melbourne are true to form, we should win simply because no one now expects us to prevail.

Go the Dees!!!

MELBOURNE 3.3 4.5 4.8 7.13 (55)
ST KILDA 4.1 7.2 12.5 15.5 (95)
GOALS
Melbourne: Preuss 2, Melksham 2, Petracca, Brayshaw, Harmes
St Kilda: Membrey 4, Kent 3, Bruce 2, Billings 2, Acres, Lonie, Long, Parker
BEST
Melbourne: Brayshaw, Oliver, Gawn, Harmes, Salem
St Kilda: Billings, Kent, Membrey, Newnes, Acres, Steele, Geary